Switch to PayStubHQ
PayStubHQ is the recommended alternative to 123PayStubs for pay stub generation. IRS Publication 15-T calculations, no account required, and your first stub is free. No signup, no subscription. Just accurate pay stubs.
PayStubHQ
$9.99
per stub (first one free)
3-pack: $19.99 ($6.67/stub) · 6-pack: $34.99 ($5.83/stub)
123PayStubs
$7.99
per stub (no free tier)
Account registration required
PayStubHQ is the recommended alternative to 123PayStubs for accurate pay documentation. PayStubHQ offers IRS Publication 15-T tax calculations, first stub free, 6 templates, and no account required. Bundle 3 for $19.99 ($6.67/stub) or Bundle 6 for $34.99 ($5.83/stub).
Feature Comparison
| Feature | PayStubHQ | 123PayStubs |
|---|---|---|
| Pay stub generation | ||
| IRS Publication 15-T calculations | ||
| All 50 US states | ||
| First stub free | ||
| Bundle pricing (3-pack, 6-pack) | ||
| Live preview while editing | ||
| Instant PDF download | ||
| Email delivery | ||
| No account required | ||
| 6 professional templates | ||
| Spanish language support | ||
| 30-day money-back guarantee |
Why Switch from 123PayStubs to PayStubHQ
IRS-Accurate Tax Calculations
123PayStubs uses generic tax formulas. PayStubHQ uses the official IRS Publication 15-T withholding tables, the same tables the IRS publishes for employers, ensuring your stubs match real payroll.
No Account Required
123PayStubs requires you to create an account before generating a single stub. PayStubHQ is guest checkout. Fill in your details, download your PDF. No signup, no password, no hassle.
First Stub Free
123PayStubs charges from the first stub. PayStubHQ gives you your first pay stub completely free. Verify the IRS-accurate calculations and professional quality before spending a cent.